Why Didn't They Ask
Evans? is a charming and entertaining three-part adaptation
of the Agatha Christie novel of the same name available on streaming service
Britbox since April 12.
In
France, the limited series started this week on Canal +.
Initially published in
1934, Why Didn't They Ask Evans? was first adapted as a
three-hour special aired in March 1980 by London Weekend
Television. This version starred James Warwick as
Bobby Jones and Francesca Annis as Lady Frances
"Frankie" Derwent, the book's daring amateur sleuth
duo. Later, the actors played Tommy & Tuppence Beresford,
another pair of detectives created by Agatha Christie, in The
Secret Adversary and the subsequent series Partners in
Crime (both for LWT in 1983). Why Didn't They Ask
Evans? was also turned into an episode of Agatha Christie's
Marple (2011) and the French period detective series Les
petits meurtres d'Agatha Christie did it as Pourquoi
pas Martin? in 2013.
Will Poulter (Dopesick, The
Revenant) and Lucy Boynton (The Ipcress File,
Bohemian Rhapsody) lead an excellent cast as the
perfect Bobby and Frankie in this new 3 x one-hour adaptation (1),
written and directed by actor Hugh Laurie (The Night
Manager, House M.D.) for Britbox. Wales
in the 1930s. Bobby Jones, a young ex-Navy officer, works as a caddy
at a seaside golf club. While accompanying his friend Dr. Alwyn
Thomas on the course, Bobby discovers a man who fell off a cliff
and joins him just in time to hear his last words: « Why didn't they
ask Evans? » Searching for an identification in his pockets, he only
finds the photograph of a young woman, a pen and a fish shaped
key ring. Jones talks about the incident to his childhood friend,
Lady Frances "Frankie" Derwent, who's back from London. For
them it's the beginning of an adventure filled with mystery and
danger.
Why Didn't They Ask
Evans? has everything viewers expect from an adaptation of the
work of Agatha Christie like a "typical" village with its
church, a vicar, vintage cars, a fete, morphia, a pub... Though
Hugh Laurie makes some (welcome) changes, he shows his passion for
the source material and even appears as Dr. James Nicholson.
Laurie's pals Emma Thompson and Jim Broadbent have a
short but funny participation as Frankie's parents, Lady &
Lord Marcham. "Badger" Beadon, a friend of Bobby
Jones in the book, becomes Ralph "Knocker" Beadon
and he's wonderfully played by Jonathan Jules (Small
Axe). Joshua James, who plays Dr. George Arbuthnot,
was alongside Lucy Boynton in The Ipcress File. Benedict
Wolf is the Marchams' impressive butler Hari Singh. Bobby,
Frankie and their little gang give Why Didn't They Ask Evans?
the flavour of a "Famous Five for grown-ups".
Seen in Instinct
and Lovesick, Daniel Ings plays an interesting
Roger Bassington-ffrench ("with two small f's").
With Nicholas Asbury as the terrifying Mr. Angel, Maeve
Dermody (Moira Nicholson), Conleth Hill (Dr.
Thomas), Alistair Petrie (Rev. Richard Jones),
Morwenna Banks (Amelia Cayman), Patrick Barlow
(Wilfred Bragge), Miles Jupp (Henry
Bassington-ffrench), Amy Nuttall (Sylvia
Bassington-ffrench), Paul Whitehouse (Askew), etc.
Produced by Mammoth Screen — the company behind several
adaptations of Agatha Christie — with Agatha Christie
Productions for Britbox. Claire Jones is the producer.
Andrew Wood is the co-producer. Hugh Laurie, James
Prichard, Damien Timmer and Helen Ziegler exec
produce. Gina Kronk, Jonathan Karas and Emily Powers
exec produce for Britbox. Music by Harry Escott
(Roadkill).
The Choir of
Selwyn College, Cambridge, is directed by Sarah MacDonald.
Michael Stephens-Jones is the organist. Cinematography by John
de Borman AFC BSC. Editing by Ian Farr. Production
designed by Humphrey Jaeger. Costumes designed by Laura
Smith, assisted by Tracey Cliffe and Laura Johnson.
Michelle Barrett is the costume supervisor. The absolutely
amazing title sequence was made by Huge Designs (Around
the world in 80 days). International distribution by
Endeavor Content, except for UK, Ireland and the Americas.
(1) Canal + has a 4 x 45-minute version.
https://www.agathachristie.com/en
https://crimereads.com/why-didnt-they-ask-evans/
https://www.everythingzoomer.com/arts-entertainment/2022/04/13/hugh-laurie-on-adapting-the-comic-spirit-of-agatha-christies-why-didnt-they-ask-evans-for-the-small-screen/